Simon laughed, thinking his song choice was just a fun mistake—until he started singing. The second he opened his mouth, regret hit him *like a tidal wave*. His face changed, the audience gasped… and what happened next left *everyone* stunned. Was this a disaster or a shocking twist? !

In 2011, Josh Krajcik, an unassuming Ohio burrito maker, stunned The X Factor with his audition. Initially met with skepticism, he sang Etta James’ “At Last” with a deep, soulful voice that silenced doubts and earned roaring applause. Simon Cowell’s doubt turned to awe as Josh’s raw talent shone through. The judges unanimously advanced him, and he finished as the 2011 runner-up. His viral performance, brimming with emotion, remains a timeless X Factor highlight.